One exit done, one on the calendar
Older comparison posts still headline two names worth re-checking. One has already left: Meta confirmed the PlayAI (PlayHT) acquisition in July 2025 as reported by TechCrunch, the Voice API was deprecated within weeks, and the domain tracker CartSignal documents the play.ht domain failing to resolve from September 2026. The other is scheduled: OpenAI's legacy tts-1 and tts-1-hd endpoints shut down on January 6, 2027, a date listed in the AssemblyAI survey linked below.
Every rate below comes from vendor pricing pages and official docs, checked on November 12, 2026. The per-vendor billing details cross-reference the November 2026 TTS pricing survey by AssemblyAI.
Published rates per million characters
Voice billing divides into two camps: per-character API rates and monthly plans with bundled credits. The table compares the per-million-character math first, because it is the most comparable unit across vendors; note that Cartesia's effective rate depends on the plan.
| Vendor / model | Rate per 1M characters | Free tier allowance |
|---|---|---|
| Google Cloud TTS Standard | $4 | 4M characters / month |
| Google Neural2 | $16 | 1M characters / month |
| Google Chirp 3: HD | $30 | 1M characters / month |
| OpenAI gpt-4o-mini-tts | Token-based: $0.60 per 1M input tokens + $12 per 1M audio output tokens (no per-character list price) | None published |
| Deepgram Aura-2 | $30 pay as you go ($27 on Growth) | One-time $200 trial credit |
| Cartesia Sonic (Startup plan) | About $39.20 effective, $45 overage | Free tier: 20K credits / month |
| Cartesia Sonic (Scale plan) | About $37.4 effective, $38 overage | Free tier: 20K credits / month |
| ElevenLabs v4 Turbo / Flash | $40 ($0.04 per 1K) | Free tier: 10K credits / month |
| ElevenLabs v4 / v3 / Multilingual v2 | $80 ($0.08 per 1K) | Free tier: 10K credits / month |
Subscription math: what the monthly plans actually buy
ElevenLabs plans run from Free (10K credits a month) through Creator at $22 to Scale at $299 (about 3.7M characters at the $0.08 v4 rate, or about 7.5M at Turbo's $0.04). The API bills the same $0.04 or $0.08 per 1,000 characters on every tier, and overage bills at that rate too; the plan fee buys the monthly allowance, concurrency and features such as cloning. A plan's effective price (fee divided by included allowance) never drops below the plain API rate, so plans are for concurrency and features, not discounts. Concurrency runs from 2 simultaneous requests on Free up to 15 on Scale for Multilingual v2, double that on Flash models. Professional voice cloning enters at Creator, $22 a month.
Cartesia sells credits at one per character: Pro $5 for 100K, Startup $49 for 1.25M, Scale $299 for 8M, with overage at $65, $45 and $38 per million. Concurrency sits at 3 on Pro, 5 on Startup and 15 on Scale. Clone slots start on Startup (2 slots), so voice cloning has a higher floor there than on ElevenLabs.
The free tiers are where budgets start, and each has a different catch. ElevenLabs Free covers 10,000 credits a month but grants no commercial license, so monetized channels must pay from the first video.
Sign-up: elevenlabs.io
Cartesia Free doubles the allowance at 20,000 credits a month, but its terms limit it to personal use.
Sign-up: cartesia.ai
Per-minute costs and the character-density trap
Converting characters to minutes depends on whose assumption holds. Cartesia counts 750 to 800 credits per minute of audio; ElevenLabs' own docs map 1,000 characters to the minute. On ElevenLabs' own assumption, a 5-minute narrated video needs 5,000 characters, which costs $0.20 on ElevenLabs Turbo; on Cartesia's assumption of 750 to 800 characters per minute, the slower-speech mapping, the same 5 minutes needs about 3,750 to 4,000 characters, or roughly $0.15 to $0.16 on the Startup tier at its $39.20 effective rate.
Two traps sit here. Dividing one vendor's published minutes by another's published minutes overstates the gap, because the two companies assume different speaking densities. And free-tier minutes drain quickly: at that density, ElevenLabs Free covers roughly 10 narration minutes a month (its credits also map 1:1 to characters, 10,000 at 1,000 characters per minute) and Cartesia Free roughly 25, fine for testing a voice, gone in one real episode.
Route the budget by workload
Stay on Google Cloud TTS if: monthly volume is large and moderate quality is acceptable; Standard voices at $4 per million with 4 million free characters monthly remain the cheapest published narration rate in this comparison.
Apply: cloud.google.com/text-to-speech
Choose Cartesia Startup ($49) if: a production app or voice agent needs low latency, dedicated concurrency (5-way on Startup) and the two professional clone slots included on that plan.
Choose ElevenLabs Creator ($22) if: monetized videos need the most expressive output; the Turbo line at $0.04 per 1,000 characters keeps the per-video cost close to Cartesia.
Pay as you go on ElevenLabs if: output stays under 100,000 characters a month and a plan commitment makes no sense yet.